Our cookies hit the trifecta of crunchy, chewy and soft. Cookie Perfection.

Traditional Cookies: $2 each  | $10 half dozen   |  $20 dozen

  • Chocolate Chip – Named as one of the best in New York
  • Sugar Cookie
  • M&M
  • Peanut Butter
  • Double Chocolate

Extraordinary Cookies: $3 each  | $15 half dozen   |  $30 dozen

  • Muddy Buddy Munchers – PB cookie swirled with chocolate and coated in Muddy Buddy Cereal mix
  • Celebration Crumble Cookie – Brown sugar sprinkle cookie with white chocolate swirls and sugar crumble
  • The Munchies – Caramel Fudge cookie, potato chips, pretzels and oreos
  • What’s For Breakfast: Cinnamon oatmeal, maple syrup and bacon

We are in the business of making things AWESOME! Check out our specialty cookie list.

Rugelach – $14 p/lb (Approx. 12 pieces)

“Not your Bubbe’s rugelach” – The Dessertist’ Mother-in-Law

  • Chocolate
  • Cinnamon
  • Birthday Cake
  • Cookies & Cream


Horseshoes – $25 dozen

These cookies are a Dessertist family recipe that has been handed down through many generations.


Custom Sugar Cookies -$3.50+ each

We can create one-of-a-kind hand painted and crafted sugar cookies to make a sweet statement. Contact us for more information: info@thedessertist.com

custom cookies